She tweeted it as an affirmation of her narrative.
When pushback occurred on that tweet due to some questions about the veracity of how that info in the study was gathered and reported, then she answered with this:
Ironically, the issue is not with just the Duke Study, but with the fact that Catherine Truitt touted it with an obvious bias herself using the official communication account on Twitter for her office.
But if she is totally confident with studies from Duke, maybe she might want to tweet the findings from other Duke studies starting with these:
That study pretty much showed how badly managed our state’s voucher system has been run. AND THAT’S DELIBERATE.
BERLIN—As U.S. authorities debate whether to keep schools open, a consensus is emerging in Europe that children are a considerable factor in the spread of Covid-19—and more countries are shutting schools for the first time since the spring.
Closures have been announced recently in the U.K., Germany, Ireland, Austria, Denmark and the Netherlands on concerns about a more infectious variant of the virus first detected in the U.K. and rising case counts despite lockdowns.
While the debate continues, recent studies and outbreaks show that schoolchildren, even younger ones, can play a significant role in spreading infections.
“In the second wave we acquired much more evidence that schoolchildren are almost equally, if not more infected by SARS-CoV-2 than others,“ said Antoine Flahault, director of the University of Geneva’s Institute of Global Health.
Schools have represented one of the most contentious issues of the pandemic given the possible long-term impact of closures on children and the economic fallout from parents being forced to stay home.
It’s alright to learn from Europe about the spread of the coronavirus.
There are 117 LEAs in NC. Add to that, the needs of elementary schools may differ from middle schools and high schools as far as reopening is concerned. There may have to be multiple plans for each school system from the smallest of counties that have only a few schools to the biggest districts with over 100 schools.
And each plan that is crafted, revised, and implemented needs to have the voices and input from those who are on the front lines and have the clearest perspectives of what happens in schools on a daily basis: certified and classified staff.
Not just teachers, but also
Therapists – speech, occupational, physical
Data Control and Clerks
Bus Drivers and Transportation
Without input from those who know schools best, any reopening plan will be just another example of people who may not know what they are really dealing with issuing ill-conceived mandates that may do more damage than good.
Over 160 days and millions of dollars wasted to keep the NCGA in “session” for 2019 and no budget was ever passed. And according to Sen. Phil Berger, it was all about teachers.
NOTHING HAS CHANGED IN OVER A YEAR.
And we are now in a pandemic.
3. REMOTE LEARNING & PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
The average school year is 36 weeks. Most school systems operate by a semester system of 18 weeks each. Split those into quarters and you have four 9-week periods that traditional schools calendars utilize.
We have spent almost three entire quarters in remote teaching and learning.
Add to that the post-planning and pre-planning involved.
And those online workshops that many teachers had to complete to learn new software packages like CANVAS.
“The General Assembly cut the budget line item for teacher professional development from the state budget during the recession and has never restored it. In 2008, the state budgeted $12.6 million for educator professional development. That line item has been reduced to zero. Now schools might pay for some professional development from other budget areas—like federal funding or state funding to support digital learning — or teachers can turn to grants.”
“Never restored” are two words most associated with public school education in North Carolina when comparing the climate right before COVID-19 to the one before the Great Recession and the advent of ALEC-inspired “reforms” to public education championed by current NCGA leadership.
Ask any professional in an ever-changing, global society about the need to keep up with latest practices and approaches to serving those who depend on them. He /she will probably cite the need to keep learning and coming into contact with others who are attempting to not staying stagnant or becoming out-of-date. They will talk about the need for ongoing professional development.
Teachers are no different. And the state of NC used to help make that happen for teachers, but in the years of a supposed economic boom, the fact that this investment in teacher professional development had not been restored and expanded is completely ignorant and outright spiteful.
And now we have this new economic downturn. If history serves as a guide, we will not be getting those funds back for professional development anytime soon. But it would be hard to not think that the past ten months have been nothing less than on the job professional development.
4. FEDERAL WAIVING OF TESTS
Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos signaled last September that the federal government will not be issuing waivers for federally mandated tests this spring because of interruptions due to the pandemic.
U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos has informed states that they should not count on getting the same waivers from federal testing mandates for this school year that they got last spring as the pandemic shut down schools.
In a Thursday letter to chief state school officers, DeVos said that these annual, summative assessments in English/language arts, math, and science are “at the very core” of the bipartisan agreement behind the Every Student Succeds Act, the main federal K-12 education law. And at a time when vulnerable students have been hurt the most by the pandemic, such tests are “among the most reliable tools available to help us understand how children are performing in school.”
Look at that last part again.
And at a time when vulnerable students have been hurt the most by the pandemic, such tests are “among the most reliable tools available to help us understand how children are performing in school.”
The woman who got her hand slapped three times by the courts for trying to divert more CARES money to private schools that do not have to be measured by such tests wants to “understand” how children are performing in school.”
But in less than three weeks, she will not be Secretary of Education any longer.
5. SEVERE TEACHER CANDIDATE SHORTAGE
Before this pandemic even started, this state was already facing a teacher candidate shortage – one that has been manufactured with “reforms” that have devalued the profession in ways that have teacher prep programs in our colleges and universities seeing a 30% drop in students. Programs like SB599 and Teach For America and TeachNC have not shown the ability to replenish that pipeline with career educators.
Now a bigger questions looms: What is NC doing to keep from having a massive teacher shortage next year?
Politicizing school reopenings, neglecting teacher input, massive workloads, and an NC General Assembly that won’t even pass a budget but cherry-picks stats to prop up a false narrative all are about to come to a perfect storm.
And the result will be a massive teacher shortage for next year.
Please remember that before the pandemic, most every school system was scratching to make sure there was a teacher in every classroom – DURING AN ECONOMIC BOOM.
6. “HERO” TO “COWARDS”
The year 2020 is all but guaranteed to reside in the mind and memories of the public school educators well after their careers in teaching are over.
At least parts of two school years will involve a virtual component or highly stressful in-person situation within a pandemic that is not anywhere under control and an election year that has already politicized school reopenings.
The goal of schooling is learning, but ironically while many are bemoaning that too many schools are “closed” we are really seeing how this six-month stark alteration of life is teaching one of the most most powerful lessons any “student” could learn.
And that lesson is that too many people in society who offer loud opinions and are capable of affecting conditions really do not understand the complexity of public schools and the obstacles that public schools and its educators face on a daily basis.
It’s not so odd then to see how in March teachers were heroes in the eyes of so many. Now, many are cowards in those same eyes.
In March, the state quickly shut down school buildings in the state due to a few known cases of a virus. That alone probably saved lives and staved off transmission. Then we had to enter the world of remote instruction literally overnight. No real preparation for it; no professional development.
In March and April, teachers and school leaders were being hailed as “heroes.” In November and December, many of those same people became “obstacles” to those who want to fully reopen school buildings.
“According to DPI budget analysts, North Carolina’s average teacher salary reached $54,682 this year. The 2019-20 average was an increase of $742 or 1.4% compared to the previous school year. DPI declares that North Carolina’s average teacher compensation ranks second only to Georgia in the Southeast. Last year, North Carolina ranked fourth in the region.”
Of course, Stoops would spin this “statistic”into an empty narrative. Even Tim Moore tweeted out some praise for this empty “victory.”
That figure is one of the most grossly manufactured statistics in this state. Let’s lay bare the facts of how that figure has come about.
The operative word here is “average”. What GOP stalwarts purposefully fail to tell you is that most of the raises have occurred at the very low rungs of the salary schedule. Of course, you can raise the salary of first year teachers by a few thousand dollars and it would give them an average raise of maybe 10-15%. You would only have to give veteran teachers a very small raise funded by longevity pay (which we no longer get) and the OVERALL average raise still looks good, and not much money has to be invested.
“Average” does not mean “actual”. But it sounds great to those who don’t understand the math.
So how can that be the average pay in NC be over 54K when no one can really make much over 52K as a new teacher in his/her entire career unless they all become nationally certified (which takes a monetary investment by the teacher to start)?
Easy. North Carolina is counting all of the veteran teachers’ current salaries in that figure. The very people whose salaries simply disgusted the former governor and the General Assembly to the point that they had to take measures to “lower” them are actually being used to tout this new wonderful “average.”
Furthermore, this average is counting on local supplements. This comes in the face of budgets that are allocating less money to each central office of each school system for administrative costs. Now each county has to raise more money to actually offset those costs and also allow for local supplements. And not all localities provide the same supplements. Imagine what the pandemic will be doing to these funds.
Remember the Leandro Report released by WestED in 2019?
It’s 301 pages.
It has 65 data exhibits in the actual report.
It has 52 data exhibits in the appendices.
And it has 12 basic findings listed below.
Finding #1: Funding in North Carolina has declined over the last decade.
Finding #2: The current distribution of education funding is inequitable.
Finding #3: Specific student populations need higher levels of funding.
Finding #4: Greater concentrations of higher-needs students increases funding needs.
Finding #5: Regional variations in costs impact funding needs.
Finding #6: The scale of district operations impacts costs.
Finding #7: Local funding and the Classroom Teacher allotments create additional funding inequities.
Finding #8: New constraints on local flexibility hinder district ability to align resources with student needs.
Finding #9: Restrictions on Classroom Teacher allotments reduce flexibility and funding levels.
Finding #10: Frequent changes in funding regulations hamper budget planning.
Finding #11: The state budget timeline and adjustments create instability.
Finding #12: There is inadequate funding to meet student needs.
As the Leandro Report by WestEd was released, it was no doubt that those who have been at the helm of budgetary control in North Carolina would try and deflect the report’s findings.
It’s been over a year AND STILL NOT ANY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT FROM STATE LEADERSHIP IN THE NCGA ON HOW TO IMPLEMENT ITS FINDINGS.
9. NEW TEACHER RETIREE HEALTH BENEFITS
If you are hired as a new teacher today or in the future, you will not have something that teachers hired before 2021 have: retiree health benefits.
A report today in the News & Observer explains that the budget set forth in 2017’s long session of the NCGA did away with retiree health benefits for hires on and after January 1, 2021 to “save money.”
How sadistic is it that in 2017 this was done and three years later we are in the middle of a pandemic and will probably have an incredible teacher and teacher candidate shortage in our public schools next fall. Retiree health benefits were a big recruitment tool for new teachers.
Now that is gone with graduate degree pay bumps and due-process rights. And longevity pay.
Oh, and that same 2017 NCGA that took away those retiree health benefits are the same people who did not expand Medicaid in 2017 or 2018 or 2019 or 2020.
10. NEW STATE SUPERINTENDENT
It will be hard for Catherine Truitt to do any worse than the puppet whose office she will take over. Actually, I would say that about anyone who follows Mark Johnson.
As I write this, this country is about to have a new president with a new Secretary of Education to be named. Betsy DeVos and her disastrous pharisaical influence will be out of office. Her stances on not waiving tests this year and funneling more monies to charters and vouchers will be replaced by someone whose wife was a public school English teacher.
Here are some questions for the new state super. Not rhetorical ones, but questions that will require answers offered through prolonged action.
What will she be doing to elevate the teaching profession here in North Carolina? That’s not really that broad of a question considering that with the combination of the pandemic’s effects and prolonged political pressure, we as a state are about to see one hell of a teacher shortage. The numbers of teachers retiring early or seeking new careers are frightening if only a quarter of the rumors I hear have any truth.
Is she going to fight for more money and resources for our public schools for not only instructional needs but for other needs like nurses, social workers, and counselors? What is she willing to do to combat what will very likely be budget cuts because of the pandemic and because of the people who control the NCGA?
How well is she going to work with the State Board of Education? Mark Johnson carried on a rather contentious relationship with the BOE. And will she speak out against the new Lt. Governor when he makes claims about how there is no systemic racism and that people who identify as gay are less than human?
What will she do to raise morale in the Department of Public Instruction? Johnson decimated it. Berger had him reorganize it. It seems to be an intentional shadow of what it used to be.
Is she going to continue to not engage with NCAE? It’s growing. Yes, it’s growing. In a state that bans public sector collective bargaining, that is a Right to Work state, that is an At Will state, and that took away graduate degree pay and due-process rights from new teachers, it seems odd that so many in Raleigh and elsewhere spend so much time and money worrying about NCAE and at the same time publicly dismiss NCAE’s influence.
But I think the most important question I have is who is she really going to listen to concerning issues about public education? Your donors? Business leaders who belong to education reform groups? Berger and Moore? Charter School groups? PEFNC? SAS? Think Tanks? ALEC? Or maybe, just maybe…teachers?
The LIGHTER the shade of blue, the more economic “distress.” This is how it was determined according to the site.
The North Carolina Department of Commerce annually ranks the state’s 100 counties based on economic well-being and assigns each a Tier designation. This Tier system is incorporated into various state programs to encourage economic activity in the less prosperous areas of the state.
The 40 most distressed counties are designated as Tier 1, the next 40 as Tier 2 and the 20 least distressed as Tier 3.
This is the salary schedule that was in effect for teachers this past school year (2019-2020).
Remember that teachers who entered the profession after 2014 no longer receive graduate degree pay increases (unless they were grandfathered in by actually being in a graduate program in 2014). Those same newer teachers will not get due-process rights either.
Remember that teachers no longer receive longevity pay and that getting NBPTS certification has to be funded by the teacher; the state used to fund the process but no longer.
Just last spring lawmakers were bragging about teacher pay during the pandemic that still ravages this country and especially this state with its rising number of infections.
$54,682 is the average teacher pay in NC according to Rep. Tim Moore.
Closing school buildings is exactly what I wanted for schools, students, teachers, and communities. After years of being in the classroom, I finally have achieved the very goal I have had since I came into the profession: getting to teach students while not having to actually be with them.
I never looked so forward to a summer as I did last summer when my usual “three” month break for “vacation” turned into weeks of self guided professional development learning online platforms that colleges usually take months to implement with in person instruction.
Teachers like me deviously proffered a narrative that forced people to think of the “community” in “community spread” as the same “community” that supports the very schools whose buildings are closed.
I even have successfully fooled people who screamed that we should close school buildings last March with barely a dozen deaths recorded statewide into thinking we should keep them closed for the numbers we have now.
I have so wanted to squeeze more out of a twenty-four period to teach both remotely and with cohorts and still be measured by standardized test scores.
This “plan” I have to make society believe that schools are just as important for mental, emotional, and social growth for students as is their intellectual growth? I thought that this would be the best way to fulfill it.
I truly wanted teachers to be considered heroes when this pandemic started so that we could be vilified months later as the pandemic got much worse.
I wanted my daughter who graduated last year to have that “unnormal” experience as a high school senior. It was deliberately done to build her character. And my special-needs son whose IEP specifically states goals for socialization and being around others so they can model behavior? I wanted him to understand that this is a prolonged lesson in independence.
Yes. This has been one big plan to make my job harder so that many in the public could think that teachers are copping out.”
This morning as I went through protocols for entering my school to work, I filled out the required questionnaire and took the mandatory temperature check. Got the “All Clear” and proceeded to my classroom.
However, it dawned on me that of the nearly 100 times that I have had my temperature checked at school (I have been on campus to teach my remote classes), never has it been 98.6 degrees Fahrenheit.
About a month right after the Thanksgiving break, I did contract COVID-19. Had symptoms, fatigue, lethargy, and low levels of energy. Sense of smell is starting is still improving.
In fact, most of the people who have come through the check points near the time I have also check in below 97 degrees. Different temperature gaugues have been used.
But most of us have consistently not been “average” unless we all are walking around with extended cases of “Walking Hypothermia” or other malady. Of course, the colder temperatures outside as we walk to the faculty checkpoint might have a lot to do with our temperature.
So, when students come back into school on a cold morning, how well is a quick temperature check going to help monitor possible cases of COVID-19?
Of course, frequently testing students and getting the vaccine to teachers quickly would be much better. And safer.
As all teachers returned to classrooms this week in my school system, I was reminded of the words spoken by Dr. Christopher Ohl about school reopenings on Nov. 19th.
“People protesting the reopening of Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools are showing a lack of understanding about science, according to Dr. Christopher Ohl, an infectious disease expert with Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center.“
And of the many positive cases that teachers have reported to their schools, hardly any cases have been officially been stated to have been transmitted while at school.
In fact, has anyone ever heard of our health department actually confirming a case of COVID transmitted in schools?
Happens at weddings.
But schools are safe.
COVID-19 cases can develop from a short dining experience on clean tables, at the union of two souls, and even in the House of God.
But not in schools. No matter who reports it or what historical data is being used. (Thanks to Justin Parmenter on this graphic).
So in just the first few weeks that kindergartners and first graders were back at schools in the WSFCS system, this was the data on the self-reported dashboard for COVID-19 (12/1/20):
AND NONE OF THEM HAPPENED IN OUR SCHOOLS.
Here it is on the first day back from Winter Holidays (1/11/21):
To put it another way:
AND NONE OF THEM HAPPENED IN OUR SCHOOLS.
At least according to authorities. Why? Because schools are that damn safe from the transmission of coronavirus. Too many important people have said so.
In fact, no cold or flu or other communicable sicknesses are transmitted at schools. If schools can keep people from contracting COVID-19, then surely schools are able to be given the credit of stopping other maladies that can be easily transmitted and keep the community spread at bay.
Or not. (And don’t let that sudden drop that you see when Monday’s reports come out fool you. Fewer test results are given on the weekends.)
Why are we even doing contact tracing in schools when there is not hardly any transmission of coronavirus ever documented by any NC health department?
Interesting that we can pin an outbreak on an event that lasted a couple of hours but not a school where people are together for days. And days. And days. Schools are that damn safe.
Michele Morrow, a parent and nurse, said teachers have a ‘great immune system” and shouldn’t worry about returning to classrooms. She said those teachers who are immunocompromised should be teaching online classes and not delaying students from returning to school.
“If you’ve been a school teacher for years, you have the immune system of steel because just like healthcare workers, you are around children all day long who aren’t the best at covering their mouth or nose when they sneeze or cough,” Morrow said. “They’re not good at washing their hands after they go to the bathroom.”
Odd that she thought teachers had immune systems “of steel” because they were in schools all day long for months.
Remember, schools are that damn safe.
If anything, teachers should have horrible immune systems because of the almost miraculous atmosphere that schools have in eradicating any transmission of communicable sicknesses because… well… schools are that damn safe.
Oh, Catherine Truitt was on the stage at that press conference too. Surprising she didn’t talk about those “steel” teacher immune systems on Fox News.
And before someone comes in to say that schools have protocols in place to combat the spread of coronavirus, then why on God’s green Earth are those same protocols not being used everywhere else?
Imagine being a student at this very juncture: a pandemic, a contentious election, and turbulent time of change.
What will you remember most if looking back at this time ten years from now? 15 years? 25? 40?
I would remember that we were sent back to school buildings when the spread of the coronavirus was at its height but schools had previously been told to close buildings for so much less when the pandemic started.
I would remember the very names of teachers and educators who were personally affected by the virus.
I would remember that our vaccine distribution seemed to be completely erratic compared to other countries.
I would remember that so many people did not obey the mandates and protocols put in place for public safety and to help curb the spread.
I would remember that hospitals were beyond capacity in a country that supposedly has the greatest resources to combat illnesses.
I would remember that so many people called for schools to reopen because of our mental and social well-being but that my school never had a full-time nurse or wrap-around services for students who really needed help before the pandemic started.
I would remember how politicized everything was concerning the virus, especially reopening schools.
I would remember how my family’s emotional, physical, and financial well-being was affected by the virus.
I would remember what happened at the Capitol on January 6, 2021.
I would remember how certain people handled the pandemic.
I would not remember what I made on standardized tests and what they actually measured.